An illustrative example. Thistlewood Residential, its communities, and all figures are fictional, modeled on typical MarketStat program results. This is not client data.

Every property-management company invests heavily in curb appeal, amenities, and marketing to get prospects in the door. But what happens next (on the phone, at the desk, on the tour, and in the 24 hours after) is mostly invisible to leadership.

Here is what a year of mystery-shop data can show for a portfolio like this: exactly what prospects experience, question by question.

64mystery shops completed
28communities evaluated
70questions per shop: phone, tour, close, and follow-up
12months of program data

Properties show well, but teams don’t close

Across the portfolio, the property itself scored 91%. The sales conversation scored far lower, and the lowest section of all was closing and handling objections.

Average score by section of the prospect journey

Property appearance
91%
Sales presentation
79%
Greeting
68%
Telephone
61%
Follow-up
55%
Closing & objections
42%
49-point gap

between how the property shows and how well the team asks for the lease. Prospects are impressed by what they see. They just aren’t being asked to commit.

Tours happen. Asking for the lease doesn’t.

The phone team does its job: more than 8 in 10 callers book a tour. But once prospects arrive, nearly 6 in 10 leave without being asked to lease, and almost half never hear from the property again. Every one of those is a warm, qualified lead the marketing budget already paid for.

Share of shops where the team did it

Set a specific tour appointment on the phone
86%
Asked the prospect to reserve the apartment that day
42%
Made a second close attempt after an objection
51%
Followed up within 24 hours
55%
Invited the prospect back for a specific return visit
12%

Five habits cause 44% of all lost points

These aren’t personality traits. They are teachable, checklist behaviors, and each ties directly to conversion or marketing ROI. Fix five habits, and the team recovers nearly half the gap.

Share of shops where the leasing team did it

Asked how the prospect heard about the community
28%
Asked the prospect to reserve that day
42%
Shared extra services and lifestyle perks
49%
Followed up within 24 hours
55%
Booked a specific return visit
12%

What gets measured gets better

Among the 22 communities shopped three or more times since the program launched, the average score rose from 55.8% on the first shop to 71.9% on the most recent, a gain of 16.1 points. Seventy-seven percent of repeatedly shopped communities improved from their first shop to their latest.

55.8%average score, first shop
71.9%average score, most recent shop
+16.1 ptsaverage improvement
52% → 86%one community, first shop to fourth, after coaching on asking for the lease

Small closing gains add up to real revenue

A quick way to see why this matters: take a portfolio, assume a modest lift in tour-to-lease conversion, and multiply it out. These are illustrative assumptions, not client data. Swap in your own portfolio’s traffic, conversion, and rent.

28communities× 20tours per community / month× 5 ptslift in tour-to-lease conversion= 28additional leases / month
≈ $454Kin annualized lease revenue (28 leases × $1,350 average monthly rent × 12 months)

There are effects that are harder to see, too: fewer days vacant per unit turn, less reliance on concessions to close, and better ROI tracking when agents ask “How did you hear about us?”

How MarketStat helps: measure, coach, re-shop, repeat

1. Measure

  • Phone, in-person, video, and recorded-call shops
  • Forms customized to your leasing standards
  • Shoppers in all 50 states

2. Coach

  • Question-level results in the Prism dashboard
  • Video and call recordings for real coaching moments
  • Summaries and location analysis in the dashboard (reports are always edited by a human)

3. Re-shop

  • Targeted shops on specific leasing agents
  • Re-shops for low-scoring communities
  • Trend tracking by property, region, and question

Your properties already win the first impression. A baseline shop of your communities, with results in the Prism dashboard in about three weeks, shows where your teams can win the lease. You can also read how coaching after a mystery shop works, or see our multifamily mystery shopping and pricing.

Get Started Download the Case Study (PDF)